In a notable regulatory appeal, a national review panel has overturned a prior decision that blocked viewers in Australia from seeing recorded content of the shooting incident involving influencer Charlie Kirk. The appeal was lodged by Elon Musk's social media platform, which contested an directive sought by the national eSafety commissioner.
Background on the Case and Ban
Following the death of Charlie Kirk at a US campus in September, the regulator petitioned the review board to assess and rate the available footage. It initially ruled the content was "unable to be classified", a rating that allowed the commissioner to instruct social media companies to restrict access to the posts for an Australian audience.
The platform X challenged the decision for a pair of videos depicting the Kirk incident. It also appealed a comparable ban on another piece of footage—showing the attack on Iryna Zarutska on a train in Charlotte—which had also been deemed "refused classification".
The Platform's Case and Final Ruling
Arguing its case, X asserted that the footage in question contained only brief violence with the weapon not shown. It was argued the footage was grainy and the camera quickly panned away from the individual to the surrounding crowd.
X argued the video was not excessively detailed, exploitative, or objectionable, stating it served as a factual documentation of "a significant incident of historical and political significance that prompted widespread discussion". The platform drew a parallel between the video and the well-known recording of President John F. Kennedy's assassination.
The majority of the review board ultimately agreed that, "notwithstanding the heinous nature of the event," the video did not reach a level that was gratuitous, exploitative or offensive enough to justify a complete ban. However, they noted that a longer or clearer version with alternative commentary might have met that threshold. Consequently, the board changed the rating of the content to R18+.
A Dissenting Viewpoint
A minority on the panel held a contrary view, contending the video was "a shareable video for the probable aim of amusement and/or benefit (such as likes, shares, or views)". This view stated the parallel with the JFK assassination tape was invalid, as that footage was made public years after the assassination, "once emotions around the matter had calmed".
Reactions to the Outcome
In a statement on its official policy channel, X expressed approval of the ruling.
"We challenged this case to uphold free speech and the critical nature of access to information about matters of public significance. We remain committed to safeguarding these principles."
Representatives for the eSafety commissioner also welcomed the board's decision, but noted that the new R18+ rating now implies platforms "must take steps to prevent R18+ material is not accessible to users under 18".
Recent Developments on Violent Content
Separately, the eSafety commissioner has not issued take-down orders to platforms this week regarding disturbing videos from the recent Bondi beach terror attack circulating on social media. The regulator stated that while the images were distressing, they did not reach the required standard for a "total ban" rating.
Instead, the companies have been instructed to apply warning labels and screens, such as blurring, on this material in accordance with their existing community guidelines.